An analysis of the peter principle

Peter principle

I found the originals occasionally worthy of a smile. Consistent with the Peter principle, the researchers found that high performing sales employees were likelier to be promoted, and that they were likelier to perform poorly as managers, leading to considerable costs to the businesses.

Programmers in a software company, for example, or administrators in local government. Peter and Hull describe six different Substitution techniques. The theory was unassailable, because nobody could consciously and rationally argue about the nature and contents of his unconscious.

An association of industrial engineers and systems experts asked me to address their convention but misinformed me regarding the date, the time, and the place. In other words, he suggested that women were frustrated because they could not be men, men because they could not bear children, boys because they could not marry their mothers and so on InEdward Lazear explored two possible explanations for the phenomenon.

They were simply victims of Dr. When Cleary received his dismissal notice he was told that he had grossly neglected the bead stringing, sandbox and other busy-work which were the things that retarded children should do.

If either of these scenarios seems familiar, you may have unwittingly fallen victim to the Peter Principle. A multitude of different explanations is as bad as no explanation at all. I noted with interest that the indoor baseball stadium at Houston, Texas, was found on completion to be peculiarly ill-suited to baseball: This is "Creative An analysis of the peter principle and several examples of successful techniques are given.

Dear old Freud might have been beatedn at his own game! Peter summed up the Peter Principle with a twist on the old adage that "the cream rises to the top" by stating that "the cream rises until it sours. People may be attracted to an organization not only by the nature of the work but also by the prospect of rapid career advancement.

First is the idea that employees work harder to gain a promotion, and then slack off once it is achieved. After final placement, an employee is likely to adopt some unusual and highly significant arrangement of his desk.

He worked with Raymond Hull on a book that elucidated his observations about hierarchies. Certainly, though, the gung-ho, simplistic way in which ideas are presented here, the way that nearly every concept gets some name with "Peter" in it, and the gross simplifications, stereotypes, and false dichotomies would be distinctly out of place in any serious or thoughtful treatment.

My investigations show that many senior employees are incapable of formulating any effective plans, for division, conquest or any other purpose. In any hierarchy any employee tends to rise to their level of incompetence.

May Learn how and when to remove this template message In chapters 1 and 2, Peter and Hull give various examples of the Peter principle in action.

My father loved The Peter Principle because it explained why life could be so maddening—and why everyone around you seems, or is doomed to become, incompetent. A competent mechanic may make an incompetent foreman; a competent school teacher may make a competent assistant principal, but then go on to be an incompetent principal, and therefore will not be considered for promotion to assistant superintendent; a military officer may be promoted all the way up through the ranks to general and still be competent at that rank, but then make an incompetent field marshal.

Lazear concluded that the former explanation only occurs under particular compensation structures, whereas the latter always holds up. The mail still went to the old address. The frequent cartoons capture much of my feeling about the book. The competence of employees at a given level can be represented by a bell curve: Entry-level jobs are often technical or specialized.

Those who realise that they are incompetent usually think mistakenly that this is only because they are not working hard enough, and so they work themselves harder until they burn out or damage their health. What Is the Peter Principle?

Peter Principle

I think everyone should at least think about the Peter Principle. About the most the tone manages is to occasionally be funny, but even that gets repetitive after a while. Is your present placement in military service, school or business your choice or are you a victim of legal or family pressure?

In any event, by this procedure of self-psychoanalysis he kicked the ladder from under his own feet. Freud, a satirist at heart, chose to explain this frustration mainly in sexual terms such as penis envy, castration complex and Oedipus complex.Aug 14,  · But the Peter Principle was more than an alarmingly nasty motto.

It was an alarmingly nasty book —and a funny one at that, illustrating the efforts of many managers to seem productive when in. Edward P.

The Peter Principle

Lazear The Peter Principle: Promotions and Declining Productivity September, 4This production structure is similar to that used in a comprehensive analysis by Gibbons and Waldman (), who also allow for.

The Peter Principle: In any hierarchy any employee tends to rise to their level of incompetence.

How to Avoid the Pitfalls of the Peter Principle

The underlying explanation, which makes immediate intuitive sense to nearly everyone I've talked to about it, is that people are promoted for being good at.

Apr 10,  · (The Peter Principle, he asserted, was “the key to an understanding of the whole structure of civilization.” He also said he was kidding.) Or maybe it was that, as much as Dr.

Make informed decisions with the FT.

Peter meant the. Daily briefing: Putin’s special trip, Kissinger on Trump, the Peter principle. US intelligence caught off guard by Trump invitation. For more M&A analysis and commentary. The Peter Principle, the eponymous law Dr.

Laurence J. Peter coined, explains that everyone in a hierarchy—from the office intern to the CEO, from the low-level civil servant to a nation’s president—will inevitably rise to his or her level of incompetence/5().

An analysis of the peter principle
Rated 0/5 based on 85 review